Medical negligence: where to complain and what you must prove
When treatment goes wrong there are regulatory, civil and criminal routes. This note explains each, the evidence that matters, and the short time limits.

The basics
A bad outcome is not, by itself, negligence. Negligence means the doctor or hospital failed to give the standard of care that a reasonably competent practitioner would have given, and that failure caused the harm.
Typical examples are operating without informed consent, giving the wrong drug or dose, leaving an instrument inside a patient, failing to act on clear test results, and treatment by an unqualified person.
Where to complain
- Provincial healthcare commission
- The Punjab, Sindh and Khyber Pakhtunkhwa healthcare commissions and the Islamabad Healthcare Regulatory Authority license hospitals and clinics and hear complaints of negligence and malpractice. They can fine, suspend or close a facility.
- Pakistan Medical and Dental Council
- Hears complaints of professional misconduct against registered doctors and dentists, and can suspend or cancel a licence.
- Civil court
- A suit for damages for the cost of treatment, lost income and suffering. Where the patient has died, the family can claim under the Fatal Accidents Act, 1855.
- Police
- Where death or injury was caused by a rash or grossly negligent act, the Pakistan Penal Code offences of causing death or hurt by mistake can apply. In practice the police and the courts rely heavily on the finding of the medical regulator or a medical board.
What to do
- 1.Ask the hospital in writing for the complete medical record: admission notes, consent forms, operation notes, drug charts, test reports and the discharge or death summary. Keep every bill and prescription.
- 2.Get a written second opinion from an independent specialist in the same field.
- 3.Write a dated account of events while memories are fresh, with the names of the doctors and staff involved.
- 4.Where a patient has died and negligence is suspected, a post-mortem may be the only way to establish the cause. That decision has to be made quickly.
- 5.File the complaint with the healthcare commission for the province and, against an individual doctor, with the Pakistan Medical and Dental Council.
- 6.Take advice early on a civil claim, because the time limit is short.
Time limits and proof
Claims for personal injury and claims under the Fatal Accidents Act generally have to be filed within one year, far less than the three years that applies to most money claims.
The patient has to prove the breach and that it caused the harm, which nearly always requires expert medical evidence. A finding by the commission or the Council carries real weight in the civil claim that follows.
About this note
Reviewed November 2026. This note gives general information about the law in Pakistan as at the review date. It is not legal advice, and the right step in a particular case depends on its facts.
Contact
To discuss a matter, write to legal@blackwell.com.pk with a short account of what happened. The first conversation is confidential and carries no obligation.
Contact us


